Brennan: Israel shouldn’t have rested Hamas battle plan ‘on the shelf’



Former CIA Director John Brennan and New York Times staff writer Ronen Bergman join Meet the Press NOW to discuss Israel’s potential intelligence failures leading up to Hamas’ October 7th attack.

» Subscribe to NBC News: https://www.youtube.com/user/NBCNews

NBC News Digital is a collection of innovative and powerful news brands that deliver compelling, diverse and engaging news stories. NBC News Digital features NBCNews.com, MSNBC.com, TODAY.com, Nightly News, Meet the Press, Dateline, and the existing apps and digital extensions of these respective properties. We deliver the best in breaking news, live video coverage, original journalism and segments from your favorite NBC News Shows.

Connect with NBC News Online!
Breaking News Alerts: https://link.nbcnews.com/join/5cj/breaking-news-signup?cid=sm_npd_nn_yt_bn-clip_190621
Visit NBCNews.Com: https://www.nbcnews.com/
Find NBC News on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/NBCNews
Follow NBC News on Twitter: https://twitter.com/NBCNews
Get more of NBC News delivered to your inbox: nbcnews.com/newsletters

#Israel #Hamas #Attack

source

32 comments

  1. Blaming now the victim? This planet is a dissaster! If there was a plan somewhere in some drawer, oh well. Let see how many plans for the destruction of all things are in drawers of secrets services all around the world. Hamas is done now. They will have many years now to plant many more plans online. A country can not live on fear for every plan that is shown somewhere.

  2. There was no land movement, Hamas worked like an animal underground, using all the resources of generous countries to build tunnels, where it stored its war arsenal. So much so that the tunnels were discovered recently, you don't want to remove hair from eggs! Machiavellian people!

  3. “Failure” my asthmatic uncle. This was all allowed to happen so Israel would have an excuse to Attack Gaza. A few years back the UN reported oil/NatGas off the Gaza coast. 2+2. It all adds up.

  4. A battle plan a year in advance? Was there a date on the plan for the attack?

  5. Sheer bloody arrogance on the part of Israeli intelligence which discounted the opposition and as to the "close intelligence relationship" between the US and Israel, I would remind everyone of Israeli duplicity in the murderous attack on the USS Liberty and the treasonous Pollards who betrayed the USA by sending classified documents to Israel.

  6. I am very interesting in this news and watch a lot of discussion on this topic. This report is the best so far.

  7. This information regarding the report it was actually exposed for the social media from the first day the attack actually happened. I’m not understanding why the people have to wait that long to see that report the Hamas militant group have released some information regarding the attack has a footage with life video camera so if you have a drones that actually destroy these laser red sensor machines what does that tell you that tell you they have information how does this machine work and using the intelligent from some of the soldiers they have been captured from 2014 and interrogating these people and asking them some questions You can read between the lines I’m sure somebody have friends somewhere continuing and keep thinking that these people that they live under siege and occupation that they’re not intelligent enough to break their prison, and to get out and attack their enemy it’s foolish
    You know the story of the monkey that you put a banana on top of his cage and he will figure out a way to get that banana and that’s only a monkey

  8. If idf had prior knowledge of this event, then to let it happen, someone in the israeli government is complicit in allowing this to happen. Now the stories are coming through that their own helicopters shot indiscriminately killing innocent civilians, and Palestinians burnt to a cinder alongside innocent civilians would highly suggest that their was alot of "friendly fire" happening, leading to the conclusion that israel has been killing it's own civilians (red flag) and blaming it on others, to justify further ethnic cleansing and genocide of Palestinians which started 75 years ago.

  9. Israel gets thousands of threats a year unfortunately.
    Some they take seriously and some they fail to take seriously.
    This threat they failed to take seriously. Nothing more

  10. Most disastrous failure since Germany 🇩🇪 invaded Poland 🇵🇱

  11. MSNBC: Must Say Nothing But CRAP.
    They are paid liars.

  12. So says the terrorist supporters, it was Hamas that broke to cease fire as they did the time before that, and the time before that, and the time before that

  13. The US new quit, trying to cover it through US rhetoric

  14. By launching this attack, Hamas actually opened the way to the Independent State of Palestine. The USA will eventually stop the war, because the USA is now trying to find allies against China. When the Chinese Armies and Armadas come to the Red Sea, the USA will choose the successful Palestinian Soldiers to fight on its behalf, rather than the incompetent Israeli Army. As far as I understand, they will prepare Marwan Barghouti as the President of Palestine for this purpose. If Realpolitik is still valid in the USA, we may soon see the Palestinian Authority in Gaza and the West Bank.

  15. IF GOD IS FOR ISRAEL, WHO CAN BE AGAINST ISRAEL. GOD OF ISRAEL IS STILL IN CONTROL. FAKE NEWS..🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱

  16. Brennan's initial analysis was spot on.

  17. The Americans also missed it!

  18. Later they (the Zionist) will come out with a video showing few terrorist admitting to their crimes…lol..can someone please give these zionist's clowns an oscar award of the year

  19. The highest political authorities who support Israel, especially Biden and his supporters, are showing their stubborn nature and supporting genocide. They show a master-class on how to turn into a stubborn donkey behind the podium and on air. They have no right to say that Genghis Khan was cruel. They are absolutely inferior to Genghis Khan and the Mongols in justice.

  20. The Zionists are unceremoniously and brazenly pushing LGBT and gender equality into politics. Thus, they intend to cut off the pro-Christian and unbelieving population of Europe, America and many other parts of the world from their offspring, to appropriate their money in endless legal disputes, and to take possession of their property. By supporting LGBT and gender equality, secular and many Arab societies sold the populations of entire countries to the Zionists, and the Vatican betrayed Christianity and sold Christians. How is safe to remain a Christian? How can you safely remain as a supporter of secularism, democracy and “democratic family values”? God doesn't tolerate this. Islam, the last law for the peaceful coexistence of people of different faiths, does not tolerate this. Therefore, traditional Muslims are a bone in the throat of the Zionists, pro-Zionist banks and governments.

  21. While the terrorist army of Israel is carrying out genocide in Palestine, the government of the Russian Federation, the offspring of the communist-Zionists, in alliance with France, the pillar of the worldwide violation of women's rights (in Islam, women have the right not to work and not to pay taxes), and the Alawite government of Assad are exterminating Sunnis in Syria. China is exterminating the Uyghurs. Zionism and communism are two jaws of the same “crocodile”. After Muslims, their target will be Christians. And then – others.

  22. Zionists, as elements of a secular way of life, brought into use 4 sins, from the point of view of Islam, which are more likely to destroy a person’s life or his family – drinking alcohol, adultery, usury and murder of a person. To Zionists, communists and secular societies, human life is a bargaining chip. Democratic values are a screen on the way to eliminating the foundations of God's providence.

  23. Zionism stands on usury. If the peace-loving part of the population stops taking bank loans, they will be weakened and lose power. This is worth to think about seriously

  24. Everyone knew but chose to let it happen as the agenda was to clear Gaza and take it on. Remember, how Satanyahu was showing a map of gaza totally clean and boasting that he will make the ME different. That ain't happening shipmate. This is the end of Satanyahu. Orange jumpsuit for him.

  25. Netanyahu new about the attack ,but he ignored it purposely so that he can start a war for his greed to claim the land of Palestinians. He doesn't know that he and Israelis are Settlers and they cannot start a war because of their position. It's a war crime

  26. If they had done something, you'd still blame Israel.

  27. Does that change the fact Hamas planned to attack innocent people on oct 7?

    No! Hamas is still the villain, because they went through with their vile attack on innocent people.

  28. Everybody is convinced that the Israelis are so smart guess what they're just like everybody else

  29. Oh man not only did they do nothing for a whole year, nothing when given a heads up by allies/neighbors a month prior, and nothing when their own military sounded the alarm at the gate, and nothing for more than five hours after the deed was done. And still to this day they do nothing to prevent this from escalating. Its not to hard to just stop and admit that what you did what you're doing and what you're going to do might still be wrong. When you can just stop and do the right thing, stop this culling. Now back to Minecraft i go